Historic decision causes tremors and division in France – Bill on assisted suicide approved

In a landmark decision expected to reshape the country's social and legal landscape, the French Lower House approved on Wednesday, July 15, the highly controversial bill allowing medically assisted suicide for patients suffering from incurable illnesses. This issue, which touches sensitive ethical and philosophical chords, continues to ignite a fierce political and social debate across France.

The green light from the Lower House and the political thriller

The approval of the legislation did not come easily. Following intense debates, the Lower House passed the text with 291 votes in favor to 241 against, reflecting the deep division within the political establishment. However, the process has not been fully completed at an institutional level. Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu announced his intention to refer the law to the country's Constitutional Council. This supreme body now has a deadline of one month to thoroughly examine the text and rule on whether it is compatible with the French Constitution.

Strict conditions and access criteria

The new law does not grant universal access but establishes an extremely strict safety framework. Specifically, the right to assisted suicide belongs exclusively to:

• It concerns only adult individuals who hold French citizenship or are legal residents of France.

• The applicant must suffer from a serious and incurable disease that directly threatens their life, being in an advanced or terminal stage.

• The condition of constant physical or psychological pain, caused by the illness and unable to be relieved, must be met.

• The patient must be in a position to freely and clearly express their will.

• Important exception: Mental illness alone under no circumstances constitutes sufficient ground or criterion for someone to request and receive this specific medical assistance. On a practical level, the law dictates that the patient receives a lethal substance which they must self-administer. In the event that their physical condition does not allow this, the administration is carried out by a doctor or nurse.

Public support, the voice of proponents, and the backlash

In contrast to the divided parliament, French society appears largely ready for this change. Opinion polls consistently record a strong majority in favor of the measure, a prime example being the Ifop poll last February, in which 84% of respondents supported the assisted dying bill. Proponents of the reform emphasize that the law offers dignity, autonomy, and control to people facing a agonizing death, while maintaining impenetrable safety safeguards. Anne Reynaud, spokesperson for the French Association for the Right to Die with Dignity (ADMD), put the issue into perspective: "Can you call it life when the suffering is so great that you can no longer do anything? From now on, people will be able to decide for themselves when and how they will die, when their pain becomes unbearable and admits no possible relief."

The "no" from the Catholic Church and conservatives

On the other side, a strong front of doctors, religious organizations, and conservative politicians is sounding the alarm. Opponents of the law argue that legalizing this practice will exert indirect social and psychological pressure on vulnerable patients, making them feel like a burden to their families and the healthcare system. The Catholic Church is leading the backlash, with one bishop openly threatening to deny Holy Communion to any MPs who support the bill. Conservative former Interior Minister and presidential candidate, Bruno Retailleau, characteristically stated: "A society based on fraternity supports, protects, and cares for people. It never abandons the most vulnerable among us."

International reality and bypassing the Senate

With this decision, France is preparing to enter an exclusive club of countries. Assisted suicide is already legally practiced in several European nations, such as Switzerland, Belgium, and the Netherlands, as well as in several US states. It is worth noting that the French Senate, dominated by conservative forces, had previously rejected the bill. However, the French institutional system dictates that the Lower House (National Assembly) has the final and decisive word, thus paving the way for this historic reform.

www.bankingnews.gr