It was early 2025 when the price of olive oil began its free fall following a brief period of high prices caused by a sharp drop in global production and low inventories.
The excuse
Prices had already begun falling significantly, yet consumers on the retail shelf continued buying at high prices. And the recurring excuse was that the 17-liter tin container was to blame for everything, simply because it spoils their game, as the selling price is lower when the product is sold directly by the producer. Today, two years later, the situation has not changed at all, and olive oil farmers have simply been driven to despair as prices have collapsed over recent months to levels below production costs.
Olive oil was to blame
The government and the Ministry of Development pretend not to understand, with Mr. Theodorikakos talking about an 8% drop in shelf prices resulting from gentlemen's agreements with supermarkets since last summer. He is the very same Minister who two years ago claimed that "if we did not have olive oil, inflation would be at 1%." Naturally, today he does not mention where inflation would stand if the collapse in producer prices had been passed on to the retail shelf, where profiteering by olive oil industrialists and distributors thrives unchecked.
The industrialists' tricks
And it thrives through practices that avoid public scrutiny, such as halting the market distribution of early-harvest olive oil (agoureleo) for roughly two years now. With early-harvest olive oil, after all, there are no excuses along the lines of having purchased it in previous months when prices were higher. Thus, today early-harvest olive oils are circulated solely by small bottlers and naturally neither influence nor shape the market.
Shelf prices
If someone conducts a small price sampling today, they will find that supermarket prices per liter (in packaging ranging from 1 to 4 liters, as 5-liter containers have vanished for psychological and marketing reasons) show Extra Virgin Olive Oil selling from 6.4 euros per liter (private label) up to 8.80 euros per liter. Of course, the major profiteering occurs with cheaper, lower-quality olive oils, virgin oils, and blends containing refined oils. For example, Altis Classic (another trick involving nomenclature, as one wonders what "classic" even means) sells at around 7.2 euros per liter in a 1-liter bottle, while Minerva Classic sells at roughly 6.3 euros per liter in a 4-liter container.
Wholesale prices in the gutter
At the same time, the average wholesale price of olive oil with acidity levels below 0.5% fluctuates between 3.1 and 3.5 euros, while virgin olive oil with acidity from 0.8% to 2% sells from 2.5 to 2.9 euros per kilogram. Naturally, the notorious refined oils contained in the "classic" type, which are essentially poor-quality oils that have undergone chemical processing, are even cheaper.
They buy in kilograms, they sell in liters
Let us examine what the above figures mean. Producers sell by the kilogram, whereas industrialists sell by the liter. This means the prices we see in the supermarket correspond to 915 grams of olive oil rather than 1,000 grams. In practical terms, this means that if a liter sells for 10 euros, the selling price per kilogram is 10.93 euros. Starting from the source, however, if we assume a merchant buys at 3.5 euros per kilogram from the producer, they effectively pay 3.2 euros per liter while simultaneously selling it at more than double the price, even though packaging and filtering costs remain relatively low. Of course, some may now cite transportation costs, and it would be helpful if they told us how much those actually impact the final price. Naturally, on lower-quality and cheaper oils, profiteering is even greater. This profiteering, however, carries another significant side effect. It keeps demand at low levels, and consequently suppresses producer prices. In essence, through the practices they employ, industrialists manipulate supply and demand, effectively shaping demand and thereby influencing prices.
They buy one quality and sell another
Naturally, the oil they purchase with an acidity of 0.3% and 0.4%, which is common in regions of the Peloponnese and Crete, is not sold directly on the shelf, as it may undergo blending with untraceable virgin olive oil, since oil with acidity up to 0.8% qualifies as extra virgin olive oil. In fact, listing the acidity level on packaging is not even mandatory, a loophole that enables practices designed to maximize profiteering. It is noted that European Regulation 2568/91 stipulates that the indication of acidity or maximum acidity may appear only if accompanied, in characters of the same size and within the same field of vision, by the peroxide value, wax content, and ultraviolet absorption. And the very fact that acidity is omitted serves as indirect confirmation of blending.
Production costs
From the above, it becomes clear that a consumer today can buy extra virgin olive oil at the supermarket for 8 euros, which has cost the industry, including packaging, laboratory analyses, promotion, and transport, less than 4 euros per liter. At the same time, olive oil producers have thrown their hands up in despair as production costs have surged (due to rising prices for fertilizers, pesticides, labor, fuel, etc.), rendering olive harvesting unprofitable. In Spain, the government withdraws surplus olive oil from the market, whereas in Greece nothing happens. And these are not the only problems facing olive oil growers, who must be divided into two categories. The first consists of full-time professional farmers, and the second comprises those who typically inherited olive groves from their parents.
The blow to production
The former are confronted, among other issues, with a complete shortage of agricultural labor, forcing them into solutions involving the employment of undocumented migrants in the country. However, this creates the side effect of reporting higher taxable income, as they cannot declare wage expenses. Any efforts made toward the organized employment of migrant workers have fallen into a void, as the sluggish Greek state brings in workers after the cultivation season has already ended. There are even farmers who spent money to legally bring in and employ migrant workers, only to see their funds wasted in the bureaucracy of the Greek state and the incompetence and inaction of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and other agencies. In an even worse position are producers who are not farmers by primary occupation. Alongside all other hurdles, they must face crushing taxation that renders cultivation entirely uneconomical. This occurs because agricultural income, for which expenses cannot be declared due to the reasons outlined above, is added to the progressive tax bracket, resulting in a tax bill exceeding actual profit. Thus, olive groves across the country are gradually being abandoned. And perhaps that is the ultimate goal. To leave nothing standing, forcing us to import inferior-quality olive oils from Tunisia and Turkey.
Nikos Karoutzos
nkaroutzos@gmail.com
www.bankingnews.gr
Σχόλια αναγνωστών